OurColony.net

Somewhat Pointless

Customer Rating:
First of all, the artwork in this book is nothing like the other Warrior Mangas. In my opinion, the anatomy and faces of the cats are just plain ugly. I would have been much more satisfied if this book had followed the style of Graystripe's books.
Also, the story is quite pointless. It's like writing a book on the secret life of Smudge. No one really cares about Sasha because she did not play a prominent role in the story and thus this is really a waste of time and energy. I don't think this book has contributed to the original Warriors series at all.

Kinda stupid

Customer Rating:
These Manga books are just a quick, easy way for the authors of the
Warrior Cat series to make some extra bucks. The books are rip-offs. In this particular one, we see the "good side" of the murderous Tigerstar and learn what a hyprocrite he was to fall for a kittypet, father children with her, and make her hide the truth about herself. It's just stupid. It doesn't even make any sense when viewed in the context of the Warrior Cats series. I commend the authors for trying to add depth to Tigerstar's character, but this was the wrong approach. And the books are small, and expensive as well! I'm all in favor of authors making money, but not like this.

A fun read

Customer Rating:
When we met Sasha in the books, she seemed like a proud, fiery cat who was happy to be independent. So here in this book we get a glimpse into her past and her meetings with Tigerstar. The art style takes a bit getting used to, but it's realistic and pretty cool. Sasha is portrayed as being much more meek and shy than when we first met her, and sort of wants to join Clan life, even though in the books it was said that she wasn't comfortable around so many cats. Nevertheless, I'm eagerly anticipating the next installment.

Interesting

Customer Rating:
This was a fairly good book, revealing much about Sasha's origins and Tigerstar's time in ShadowClan. Sasha is much more meek than how she is portrayed in the TNP series, and her feelings for Tigerstar and her reasonings for wanting to be with him are explained. The story is told from her vantage point, up to the end where we are left waiting for the next book. It is admittedly overshadowed by the great Eclipse, (properly named) which has brought back Warriors fans everywhere, but the art is good, and I am left anticipating the next book, which promises even more. The book is slightly overpriced for one of it's size, and the fact that it is not an actual novel, but I do recommend that you read this one.